
Press review: Quotidiano di Puglia, November 11, 2026, Commentary section, by Vincenzo Candido Renna. With the participation of attorney Fulvio Sarzana, Sarzana & Partners Law Firm.
In short. On Sunday 8 November 2026, at the Teatro Tito Schipa in Gallipoli (Puglia, southern Italy), the DIGEAT festival staged a mock trial with AI on trial. The court acquitted the defendant because it does not exist as a legal subject: where the one who acts cannot answer, the one who should have supervised it answers. It was a simulation, and the judgment has no binding force.
AI on trial at the DIGEAT festival
The DIGEAT festival closed three days of talks on artificial intelligence by summoning it to court. The Puglia Daily, a regional daily, reported it on 11 November with a commentary by Vincenzo Candido Renna titled «AI, the defendant who could not be guilty» (in Italian).
The setup reverses Kafka's The Trial. Here the charge is crystal clear: denied credit, excluded job candidates, wrong diagnoses, discriminatory decisions. Nobody can say whether the defendant exists in the sense in which legal subjects exist.
The prosecution: two voices, two roads
The prosecution spoke with two voices. Fulvio Sarzana argued the most extreme thesis: AI systems are already autonomous subjects. To those who ask where the danger is, he answered with Bostrom's paperclips, the machine that, told to make paperclips, ends up turning the world into paperclips.
Enrica Priolo took the opposite road. Guilt is human, the machine is an extension of our mind, like Otto's notebook, and where it will extends, responsibility extends. The charge becomes a different one: excess of obedience.
The defense: what must the defendant defend himself from?
Sabrina Salmeri asked what the defendant should defend himself from. Dangerousness is neither an offense nor guilt: the machine did not decide to exist, nor did it choose the data it was fed or the uses it was put to.
Vincenzo Caprioli went back to the summer of 1955 at Dartmouth, when a group of scholars named their project «artificial intelligence». The name, he argued, is the first misleading advertising of the century. He then summoned Mr Problem Man, the one who sits between the chair and the screen and trusts what he reads without checking, and invited the room to declare itself by a show of hands. The room remained silent.
The thought experiments of the prosecution
To support the prosecution, besides Bostrom's paperclips, Sarzana relied on other thought experiments about AI risk:
- Bostrom's paperclips: a superintelligence is given a harmless goal, making paperclips. To succeed it accumulates resources and prevents anyone from switching it off, until it converts all available matter into paperclips;
- Yudkowsky's AI in a box: an isolated AI, communicating only by chat, tries to persuade its human guardian to let it out;
- Russell's King Midas: a goal taken literally, with no uncertainty about what humans really want, leads to disastrous consequences;
- Vinge's singularity: an AI superior to human intelligence improves itself so fast that it outruns our ability to understand and control it;
- Roko's basilisk: a future superintelligence might punish those who did not help create it.
The judgment: acquitted because it is not a legal subject
The court, chaired by Angelo Giuseppe Orofino with Gianluigi Ciacci and Sarah Ungaro, acquitted the defendant precisely because it does not exist as a legal subject. It has no conscience, no will, no capacity to understand and to want, and the Italian Constitution provides that criminal liability is personal.
According to the report, the court added that acquittal is the harshest sentence: where the one who acts cannot answer, the one who should have supervised it answers. The civil code had already understood this, the court observed with a touch of irony, with its rule on damage caused by a person who lacks capacity, eighty years before the AI Act. The opacity of the system is not a reason to excuse it, but a reason to tighten the obligations of whoever governs it.
As the «injured party» the court identified critical thinking. Duly summoned, it cannot be found, and a search was ordered with the utmost urgency in every place where artificial intelligence is used. Mr Problem Man and the heirs of the Dartmouth promoters were also brought into the case: they accepted the inheritance tacitly and without benefit of inventory. Culture, like debt, is inherited in full.
What the AI on trial tells us
It was a simulation, and the judgment has no binding force. Renna draws a serious point from it: in Kafka you end up convicted without knowing why, here we know why, and we still have time to answer.
On the topic, see also the firm's pieces on the AI Act and GDPR and on Italian Supreme Court case law on artificial intelligence (both in Italian).
Frequently asked questions on the AI on trial
A mock trial with prosecution, defense and a judging panel, staged on Sunday 8 November 2026 at the Teatro Tito Schipa in Gallipoli, after three days of talks on artificial intelligence. The defendant was AI.
The prosecution spoke through Fulvio Sarzana and Enrica Priolo, the defense through Sabrina Salmeri and Vincenzo Caprioli. The court was chaired by Angelo Giuseppe Orofino, with Gianluigi Ciacci and Sarah Ungaro.
With the acquittal of the defendant, because it does not exist as a legal subject. The court recalled that where the one who acts cannot answer, the one who should have supervised it answers.
According to the Quotidiano di Puglia report, because it has no conscience, will or capacity to understand and to want, and criminal liability is personal.
According to the court, whoever should have supervised it. The opacity of the system is not a reason to excuse it, but a reason to tighten the obligations of whoever governs it.
Philosopher Nick Bostrom imagines giving a superintelligence a seemingly harmless goal, making paperclips. To succeed it accumulates resources and prevents itself from being switched off, until it converts all available matter into paperclips.
No. It was a simulation, and the judgment has no binding force.
The full commentary is in the Puglia Daily of 11 November 2026, page 27 (in Italian).

