The Senate amends the Consolidated Law on Privacy
by Cristiana Coviello www.lidis.it
The Senate's approval of the bill converting Legislative Decree no. 10 of 21 January 2004, which provides for urgent measures to address health emergencies, has impacted the new Consolidated Law on Privacy (Legislative Decree 196/03), introducing changes to some provisions aimed at establishing provisions for the protection of users' fundamental rights. .
In recent weeks it had appeared in the press the dissent of one of the categories affected by the new Consolidated Law on the assumption that the excessive analytical nature and cumbersomeness of the procedures for data processing in the healthcare sector would, in fact, lead to the paralysis of their outpatient activity.
The impetus for the change was promoted by general practitioners, the so-called family doctors, who were required by the new Privacy Code to comply with complex procedures that, in their opinion, were appropriate for public or private healthcare facilities, but deemed disproportionate to the reality represented by the personal and fiduciary relationship between family doctors and their patients, which is well regulated by codes of ethics.
What has changed.
The amendments made by the Senate specifically concern some articles of the Consolidated Law.
Article 37 regulates the notification of data processing to the Guarantor: the old text has been supplemented by a provision stating that notification is not required if it relates to the activities of family doctors and pediatricians of free choice.
The reasons behind the amendment to the law, as also expressed in the parliamentary debate, lie in pressure from the medical association, which believes that the procedure required for notification to the Guarantor is complex and too costly.
In fact, doctors emphasized that the forms, which had to be downloaded online and sent electronically with a digital signature, would be too complicated.
In reality, as the Guarantor clarified in a note sent to parliamentarians, the new Privacy Code has not introduced any general notification requirement for general practitioners and pediatricians. Article 37, in fact, specifically lists the cases in which notification is required (for example, in the healthcare sector, the processing of genetic and biometric data, for the purposes of assisted reproduction, etc.) without specifically mentioning general practitioners and clearly implying that, given the nature of the data processed, these requirements do not apply to the professionals in question.
The second measure concerns Article 83, which requires healthcare providers to adopt measures to ensure respect for patients' fundamental rights and freedoms in organizing their services. These measures are described in detail, including: solutions aimed at respecting a priority and call order, regardless of identifying patients by name, the use of courtesy distances and voice devices, and solutions designed to prevent undue access by third parties to information that could reveal a patient's health status. The imposition of these measures has sparked considerable criticism due to the difficulty of implementing them within a private medical practice. In this case, particular conflict was caused by the distances of courtesy and, above all, the doctor's call for a fee, which would be in stark contrast with the concept of the doctor-patient relationship of trust, according to which respect for the rights, freedoms and dignity of the human person can well be protected by the codes of ethics of doctors signed pursuant to art. 12 of the Consolidated Law.
The new text, therefore, with the implemented modification, excludes family doctors and pediatricians of free choice from the application of such measures.
However, the danger of this change is that it creates a clear differentiation of rules for public and private healthcare facilities compared to those for family doctors and pediatricians. This could lead to a "free zone" for this category, no longer required, formally or by law, to respect the dignity and confidentiality of the patient.
A further change has been made to the rules governing "new" prescriptions for medicines. Legislative Decree 196/03 introduced rules that had sparked considerable controversy among medical and pharmacists' associations. This applies both to the new paper prescription form for medicines covered by the National Health Service (NHS), which requires a special slip prepared on paper (or using a copying technique, to be placed on the area of the form indicating the patient's personal details), and to the physician's obligation not to include the patient's personal details on the prescription for medicines not covered by the National Health Service (NHS).
The new law, however, stipulates that patient anonymity on prescriptions be subject only to an explicit request from the interested party. This innovation, inspired by the desire to simplify the physician's work, may, however, create an ill-conceived conflict of interest in the legislation, as well as further bureaucratic burdens. Indeed, the application of this choice will mean, in practice, that the physician will have to ask the patient what his or her wishes are each time, and will have to document this expression, in compliance with the guiding principles of the Privacy Code, in order to avoid subsequent disputes regarding the inclusion of the patient's personal details on the prescription. Consequently, therefore, a series of issues will have to be addressed, not least that of which is that the Ministry of Health prepare a further model for prescriptions, or again modify the one indicated in the Consolidated Law, to be used according to the interested party's indications.
Finally, the transitional provisions have amended the implementation deadlines set out in the Code. Specifically, those provisions requiring general practitioners and pediatricians to inform patients and obtain consent, as required under Articles 78 and 81 of the Code, upon initial contact or no later than September 30, 2004, have been amended. The new regulation does not set a deadline by which the family doctor must inform the patient. In this case, therefore, since there is no deadline by which such a prescription must be issued, it can be set immediately. This means that doctors would have had to provide information and obtain consent as early as January 1, 2004.
What happens from today
Questions raised in the Senate must be approved by the Chamber of Deputies.
If they are confirmed by the other house of Parliament, the scenario that will unfold will be one of different behavior among family doctors. The problem that will arise, then, will be the processing of personal data without the obligation to notify the Guarantor; and this in the absence of an obligation to comply with general rules established in the healthcare sector (protecting the dignity of the individual and privacy), which are left to the self-regulation of codes of ethics.
Family doctors will also be required to inform patients for each prescription and collect their consent to provide personal information. This violates the rules on simplified procedures for providing information and consent.
To this end, one might ask: Is this amendment to a Code that has been in force for only two months really useful?
And again, are these requested changes really necessary, or is it just an uncritical adherence by Parliament to a partisan request?
The answer is for lawyers, technicians, and above all, patients.

