SARZANA and Partners Law Firm wins for Telenia against Infratel Italia s.p.a.

SARZANA and Partners Law Firm wins for Telenia against Infratel Italia s.p.a.

Vouchers for ultra-broadband connectivity: Infratel Italia S.p.A. found guilty of late payments to operator Telenia.

 

Rome, February 9, 2026

 

Infratel Italia Spa, an in-house company of the Ministry of Business and Made in Italy, was sentenced on February 13, 2026 by the Second Section of the Civil Court of Rome, represented by Judge Alessandra Imposimato, to pay the electronic communications operator Telenia all interest on the sums due as reimbursement for ultra-broadband connectivity vouchers, from the due date of the invoices, in addition to the payment of legal costs quantified, with accessories, at almost 13 thousand euros.

The operator, assisted by the lawyers Fulvio Sarzana di S.Ippolito and Maria Sole Montagna, of the Sarzana e Associati Law Firm in Rome, had submitted a request for over 61 thousand euros, plus 45 thousand subsequently, due to delays in the reimbursements paid, and has therefore obtained a significant victory in court, in a dispute that could have an impact on all future disputes brought by anyone in the broadband sector.

The operator had obtained an injunction for the sums owed by Infratel under the Broadband Voucher plan, but Infratel had opposed it before the Rome Court.

During the trial, Infratel paid all the sums due to Telenia, albeit with considerable delay. However, the Judge nevertheless ordered Infratel to pay the operator interest on the delayed commercial transactions pursuant to Legislative Decree no. 231/2002, in addition to legal costs.

The Court held in particular that: "It is therefore clear that the plaintiff should have initiated the payment (refund) in installments of the vouchers activated by the operator within the month following activation, dividing the amount into monthly installments consistent with the duration of the contract stipulated between the operator and the end customer, beneficiary of the discount.
The contract does not contain any condition (art. 1353 et seq. of the Civil Code) or other clause from which it could be deduced that the payment demanded in court was in any way subordinated or in any case conditioned by the acquisition of the necessary financial resources by the obligated debtor.

“Since what was agreed between the plaintiff and the Ministry of Enterprise and Made in Italy in the Technical Plan exhibited in the
deeds, since it concerns a transaction stipulated inter alios, and as such unenforceable (art. 1372 paragraph 2 of the civil code) against the defendant opposing today, it goes without saying that the only reason for opposition must be considered unfounded.”

The Court therefore ruled as follows: "The Court of Rome, definitively ruling in the first instance civil case indicated in the epigraph, every different request, conclusion and deduction rejected, thus provides:

– given the subsequent payment, during the course of the proceedings, of the capital sum of the contested injunction, as well as the fate of the counterclaim formulated by the opposing defendant, at the time of its appearance in court:

  • revokes injunction no. xxxx/2024, issued on 6 June 2024 at the request of Telenia Srl;

– rejects, for the rest, the reasons for opposition, and for the effect:

  • orders Infrastrutture e Telecomunicazioni per l'Italia SpA to pay Telenia Srl the interest referred to in Articles 4 and 5 of Legislative Decree No. 231/2002 on the amount of the installments indicated in the summary judgment, from the respective due dates to the date of actual payment;

– orders the opponent to reimburse the opposing party, Telenia Srl, for the legal costs, which it liquidates as €379.50 for disbursements, €10,000.00 for legal fees (calculated on the value of the dispute: €61,455.71 + €45,831.56), in addition to general expenses under 15%, VAT and CPA as required by law.”

 

SARZANA and Partners Law Firm wins for Telenia against Infratel Italia s.p.a.

1 thought on “SARZANA e Associati Studio Legale vince per Telenia contro Infratel Italia s.p.a.”

Comments are closed.

en_GBEnglish
WeeJay