CUP Telecoms: How to Respond to Municipalities, the Article in Agenda Digitale

CUP Telecoms: How to Respond to Municipalities, the Article in Agenda Digitale

by Maria Sole Montagna and Fulvio Sarzana di S. Ippolito, Attorneys, Sarzana & Partners Law Firm

In short. CUP telecoms: many telecom operators receive by certified email (PEC) a request from Italian municipalities for the Unified Property Fee (Canone Unico Patrimoniale, CUP) for the years from 2021 onwards. The deadline to reply to an invitation to a hearing is 60 days from receipt. To build the defence, what counts is checking the lines, telling an invitation to a hearing from an enforceable assessment, and the technology used to provide the service.

In Agenda Digitale (in Italian), Maria Sole Montagna and Fulvio Sarzana explain CUP telecoms and how to respond to municipalities. These are the main points. See also the earlier article on why operators risk new payments (in Italian).

CUP telecoms: the situation

The first wave of requests arrived as enforceable assessments already issued, with the municipality of Bologna among the first to move in spring. Now a more widespread communication is added: the invitation to a preventive hearing, sent even by small municipalities. Operators receive it even if they never installed a metre of cable in that territory.

Two rulings of the Court of Cassation (Italy’s Supreme Court) changed the picture. On 1 May 2026 the Joint Sections classified the CUP as a tax in every form: disputes go before the tax court. The same decision extended the payment obligation to whoever uses another party’s infrastructure indirectly, with no concession to occupy public land.

On 28 April 2026 the civil section then reversed a judgment of the Court of Lodi that favoured operators: whoever sells services through virtual access to third-party networks, using VULA technology, also owes the fee. Municipalities use the two rulings as a basis to widen their checks.

How municipalities calculate the CUP telecoms fee

Some municipalities cross the lists supplied by a large national operator with the list of operators active in their territory. Others work from their own records. In both cases the number of lines quoted in the notice is often conventional: many operators never sent the annual declaration of lines, due by 30 April, and the authority applies the legal minimum.

In CUP telecoms the minimum fee is 800 euro a year, revalued with ISTAT indices. With four years, from 2021 to 2024, the total comes close to 4,000 euro, as a provisional estimate and without penalties or interest.

If the municipality skips the discussion and serves an enforceable assessment directly, a penalty of up to 30%, late-payment interest and notification costs are added. The extra burden is felt even on a single contested year.

Hearing invitation and assessment: what is the difference

The invitation to a preventive hearing is provided for by Article 6-bis of the Taxpayer’s Charter. The municipality previews the draft of the act and gives the company time to put forward its arguments. It has no final effects, it cannot be appealed and it creates no immediate payment obligation.

The enforceable assessment takes effect at once: if it is not paid or contested in time, it becomes the basis for forced collection. Knowing which stage you are in decides the strategy. In the first you work so that the final act is never adopted, in the second you are already within the tight deadlines for an appeal.

How to respond to a municipality’s CUP request

The first mistake is not to respond: the deadline is 60 days from receipt, after which the municipality can proceed. The article lists these steps, in order:

  • check whether the municipality has any active lines, today and in the years covered by the request; if there are none, a formal statement of their absence is enough;
  • if lines exist, reconstruct how the service is delivered: own network, FiberCop or Open Fiber fibre, bitstream, VULA, Easy IP, wholesale on a third-party network, because the technology changes the legal classification;
  • ask for access to the documents the request is based on, including any lists or data the municipality used: an external list, not independently verified by the authority, has limited evidentiary weight;
  • file written submissions within the 60 days, asking where useful for a meeting with the officer in charge.

CUP assessment already served: self-review and appeal

A request for self-review (autotutela) remains possible, but in practice it is granted almost only when the operator shows it has no active line in the territory. In the other cases the route is an appeal to the competent Tax Court of Justice, within the deadlines running from service. It is still worth filing the self-review request: even if rejected, it becomes a useful attachment to the appeal.

VULA, bitstream and Easy IP in operators’ defence

This is the point on which much of the CUP telecoms litigation will be played in the coming months. The Court of Cassation has held that VULA, although a virtual access, amounts to indirect use of the physical infrastructure and therefore creates the obligation to pay the fee.

For bitstream and Easy IP the argument remains different: it is a logical access that involves no use, even indirect, of the physical infrastructure in the territory. No rulings are known that clearly equate these modes with VULA. The defence has to be built on precise technical and contractual elements: the type of contract with the network operator, the absence of owned equipment, the actual features of the service sold to the end customer.

CUP telecoms: the operational summary

Note the 60-day deadline immediately. Check the real position in each municipality. Reconstruct the delivery technology before writing any reply. Always ask for access to the documents. And tell, case by case, whether there is still time for a preventive defence or whether the act must be appealed within deadlines already running.

On the topic, see also the firm’s piece on the CUP and electronic communications operators after the Court of Cassation (in Italian).

Frequently asked questions on CUP telecoms

Why are municipalities asking telecom operators for the CUP?

After two 2026 rulings of the Court of Cassation, municipalities are widening their checks: the Joint Sections extended the obligation to whoever uses another party’s infrastructure indirectly, and the civil section held that whoever sells services using VULA technology also owes the fee. The requests arrive by certified email and cover the years from 2021 onwards.

How much CUP does a telecom operator pay?

The minimum fee is 800 euro a year, revalued with ISTAT indices. With four years, from 2021 to 2024, the total comes close to 4,000 euro, without penalties or interest. With an enforceable assessment, a penalty of up to 30%, late-payment interest and notification costs are added.

What is the difference between an invitation to a hearing and an enforceable assessment?

The invitation to a preventive hearing previews the draft act, has no final effects, cannot be appealed and creates no immediate payment obligation. The enforceable assessment takes effect at once and, if not paid or contested in time, becomes the basis for forced collection.

By when must an operator respond to the municipality’s CUP request?

Within 60 days from receipt. After that the municipality can proceed with no further steps. It is advisable to check the lines, reconstruct the service technology, ask for access to the documents and file written submissions within the deadline.

What can be done if the CUP assessment has already been served?

A self-review request can be filed, which in practice is granted almost only if there are no active lines in the territory, and an appeal can be brought before the competent Tax Court of Justice within the deadlines running from service. The self-review request, even if rejected, is a useful attachment to the appeal.

Are VULA, bitstream and Easy IP treated the same for the CUP?

No. The Court of Cassation held that VULA amounts to indirect use of the physical infrastructure and creates the obligation to pay the fee. For bitstream and Easy IP it can be argued that the access is logical and involves no use of the infrastructure, but no rulings clearly equate them with VULA.

The full article is on Agenda Digitale (in Italian).

it_ITItalian
WeeJay