AGCOM'S PIRACY SHIELD AND CLOUDFLARE: THE LAZIO TAR INTERVENES
The Communications Regulatory Authority (AGCOM) must provide access to the investigative reports and attachments relating to the proceedings initiated under the anti-piracy system called “Piracy Shield”.
The legal principle, contained in a collegial order of the Lazio Regional Administrative Court (TAR) at the end of April this year, led to the partial acceptance of the appeal against AGCOM's denial of access to documents to Cloudflare, the subject of a sanctioning proceeding before the Authority itself.
In this regard, the TAR ruled as follows: “This Panel believes that, with reference to the preliminary investigation reports and related attachments (Council meetings of 6 November, 17 and 29 December 2025), the situation exists that legitimizes defensive access.
In this regard, it should be noted that, in the appeal against the contested resolution, Cloudflare alleged specific investigative flaws.
The reports of the offices—as procedural documents that contributed to the formation of the Authority's intention—are therefore documents of abstract defensive importance for the purposes of protecting the legal position of the appellant, who has a concrete and present interest in contesting the imposed fine of €14,000,000.
This solution is in line with the teaching of the Plenary Assembly of the Council of State, according to which, once the instrumental connection between the document and the final situation to be protected has been ascertained, the Public Administration and the access judge must not carry out any "«further evaluation of the admissibility, influence or decisiveness of the requested document»", with such assessment being the exclusive responsibility of the judge on the merits. In this case, there is no evidence of a pretextual or reckless exercise of access, given the direct relevance of the documents to the sanction file.
Nor can the denial of access be validly based on AGCOM's reference to the exclusion clauses set forth in Article 13, paragraph 1, letter a) of its Access Regulation (Resolution 383/17/CONS as amended by Resolution 205/23/CONS), which excludes access to notes, memos, and preliminary drafts.
FOLLOWS ON NOVA-IL SOLE 24 ORE
AGCOM'S PIRACY SHIELD AND CLOUDFLARE: THE LAZIO TAR INTERVENES


